How It Works
This calculator compares the total cost of ownership for hiring an in-house employee versus outsourcing to a contractor or agency. In-house costs include base salary, benefits and taxes (typically 25-50% of salary), one-time recruitment and training costs amortized over the comparison period, annual equipment and software, and management overhead for supervision and HR administration.
Outsourcing costs include the contractor or agency rate, plus management overhead for coordination and quality control. While contractors often have higher hourly or project rates, they eliminate benefits, payroll taxes, recruitment, training, and equipment costs. The calculator projects both options over multiple years to show when break-even occurs and which option is more cost-effective long-term.
Use this tool to make data-driven hiring decisions, evaluate specific roles for outsourcing potential, or build a business case for either approach with your finance team.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I include in the benefits multiplier?
+
Include employer payroll taxes (Social Security, Medicare, unemployment), health insurance, retirement contributions, paid time off, bonuses, and other benefits. In the US, this typically ranges from 25-40% of base salary. Countries with national healthcare may be lower (20-30%), while those with extensive statutory benefits can be higher (40-60%). Use 35% as a default estimate.
How should I estimate recruitment costs?
+
Include job posting fees, recruiter commissions (typically 15-25% of first year salary), background checks, interview time cost, and offer negotiation. Average recruitment costs range from $3,000-$5,000 for entry level to $15,000-$30,000 for executive positions. Factor in the cost of multiple hiring rounds if turnover is likely.
When does outsourcing make more sense?
+
Outsourcing often wins for: specialized skills needed short-term, variable workload, roles requiring expensive tools or certifications, positions difficult to recruit locally, or when you want to test demand before committing to full-time headcount. Long-term core functions typically favor in-house as one-time costs amortize over time.
What about quality and control differences?
+
This calculator focuses on direct financial costs. In-house typically provides better cultural fit, institutional knowledge, and direct control. Outsourcing offers flexibility, specialized expertise, and scalability. Consider: how strategic is the role, how much domain knowledge is required, what level of integration with your team is needed, and how important is availability and responsiveness.
How accurate are these projections?
+
Projections depend heavily on your input accuracy. Hidden costs can include: turnover and replacement hiring (average tenure is 3-4 years), productivity ramp-up time (3-6 months), management time for both employees and contractors, and potential quality issues requiring rework. Add 10-20% buffer to both options to account for unknowns.